News

Puritan Gems

Tuesday, September 20, 2016

A False Dichotomy

A friend recently put up a short post on Facebook in which he dichotomises faith and science:

'There are 2 ways of looking at the World: faith & superstition, or the rigours of logic, observation & finally evidence. Reason & a respect for evidence are the only sources of human progress, they also provide a safeguard against fundamentalists & those who profit from obscuring the truth.'

It is the standard stuff we see from atheists, the usual quasi-scientific piety that collapses upon inspection. The quote is worth reproducing here since this view (in some or other variation) is so common among atheists and accepted as being self-evidently true.

'There are 2 ways of looking at the World: faith & superstition, or the rigours of logic, observation & finally evidence.'

1. As is all too common, the dichotomy is set up. Faith and superstition on one side, logic, observation and evidence on the other, with no sense of compulsion to argue for such a dichotomy. It is an unquestioned assumption and it is extremely simplistic and problematic.

2. Faith and superstition are put side by side with the negative connotation that they are necessarily in the same backward category, while science, of course, is free from all and any type of faith.

3. 'Faith' is thrown out with the intention of being derogatory, with no thought given to the term and how it can hold different levels of meaning in different contexts.

4. Biblical faith is multifaceted, and is very much an evidence-based faith, and not blind faith on a level with superstition, as the quote wants to suggest.

5. The quote fails to understand that certain scientific theories must be taken by faith. Take the standard and widely accepted Darwinian 'theory' of origins. The hypothesis of common descent and transformation is a hypothesis which has not been derived from the observational sciences, and is therefore a hypothesis that must largely be accepted on faith.

6. The atheist presupposes that the origin of the universe and all of life arose by purely naturalistic means. This is not a scientific position but rather a philosophical position, and it is a position that requires, one might say, an astonishing level of faith.

7. Atheism itself, from which these grandiose statements find their basis and confidence, is a belief which ultimately requires faith. Atheism is not some default position that is true unless proven otherwise; atheism shoulders a tremendous burden of responsibility, yet it is taken as a given by a vast number of its adherents.

'Reason & a respect for evidence are the only sources of human progress...'

1. Again, this sounds very grand, very noble. Trouble is, it is fundamentally flawed as, again, it presupposes reason and evidence are opposed to and separate from faith.

2. On a naturalistic scheme of things, how can one be sure that one's reasoning faculties are accurately corresponding with the world around them? If one believes that one's sense organs developed from blind, physical, non-purposeful natural forces, then how can one be sure that these sense organs provide accurate information about the world beyond themselves rather than simply inferred from them? The atheist must take by faith that their reasoning faculties are giving them accurate information about the world beyond those reasoning faculties.

3. Moreover, how can the atheist justify the validity of their reasoning faculties without appealing to their reasoning faculties, thus engaging in viciously circular argumentation? Again, the atheist must take by faith the validity of their reasoning faculties.

4. On atheism, what is human progress? To propagate one's genes, perhaps? But given evolutionary assumptions, whence lies the imperative to propagate one's genes? Why ought the human species keep on moving?

5. On Christianity, human progress can encompass a number of meaningful aspects, for example by cultivating right and wrong and moral and ethical norms in ourselves and in our young; by bringing ourselves and our young closer to the creator by studying His word and keeping His precepts; by loving our neighbour and impressing upon them that we are all image bearers of God with intrinsic value, purpose and significance to our lives; by sharing the Gospel of Jesus Christ, and aiming for the ultimate in human progress by means of the Spirit bringing the unbeliever out of bondage and into eternal salvation. It is the Christian who can rightly and without contradiction speak of human progress.

'...they also provide a safeguard against fundamentalists & those who profit from obscuring the truth.'

1. Again, this is a mere rhetorical device that doesn't really mean anything.

2. Are there 'fundamentalists' (typically, 'fundamentalists' here is being applied to all believers, with a complete misunderstanding of, and thus narrow, derogatory use of, the term) who wish to profit from their output, no matter how accurate that output? Sure. Richard Dawkins, I believe, in his The God Delusion, would qualify as one such wild-eyed, unthinking fundamentalist (properly applying the derogatory usage here). So what? Are all atheists unthinking, swivel-eyed, humanist manifesto-thumping fundamentalists?

3. Traditionally, of course, a Christian fundamentalist would be one who holds to the fundamentals of the Christian faith. Unfortunately, the term has taken on a life of its own, with many an atheist showing no willingness to apply the term – and thus represent the Christian – accurately

Interestingly, we must conclude that the claim,

'There are 2 ways of looking at the World: faith & superstition, or the rigours of logic, observation & finally evidence. Reason & a respect for evidence are the only sources of human progress...'

is itself a claim that cannot withstand the scrutiny of logic and reason.

Soli Deo Gloria

6 comments:

South Florida wrongful death lawyer said...

Hi there! This is kind of off topic but I need some advice from an established blog. Is it very hard to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty quick. I’m thinking about setting up my own but I’m not sure where to start. Do you have any points or suggestions? Thank you

Danny said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Manish Packers and Movers Pvt Ltd said...

Manish Packers and Movers Pvt Ltd as a Services providing company can make all the difference to your Home Relocation experience. Indore based Company which offers versatile solutions, Right team that easily reduce the stress associated with a Household Shifting, Vehicle Transportation. we help things run smoothly and reduce breakages and offer you seamless, Affordable, Reliable Shifting Services, Compare Shifting Charges, Visit :
https://www.manishpackersmoversindore.in/
https://www.manishpackersmoversindore.in/packers-and-movers-indore.html
https://www.manishpackersmoversindore.in/manish-packers-and-movers-indore.html
https://www.manishpackersmoversindore.in/packers-movers-gurgaon.html
https://www.manishpackersmoversindore.in/packers-movers-kolkata.html
https://www.manishpackersmoversindore.in/packers-movers-mumbai.html
https://www.manishpackersmoversindore.in/packers-movers-jaipur.html
https://www.manishpackersmoversindore.in/packers-movers-nagpur.html
https://www.manishpackersmoversindore.in/packers-movers-raipur.html
https://www.manishpackersmoversindore.in/packers-movers-ahmedabad.html

Manish Packers and Movers Pvt Ltd said...

Movers and Packers Dewas Naka Indore
Movers and Packers Vijay Nagar Indore
Movers and Packers Scheme 54 Indore
Packers and Movers Delhi
Packers and Movers Pune
Packers and Movers Jodhpur
Packers and Movers Kanpur
Packers and Movers Ghaziabad
Packers and Movers Noida
Packers and Movers Navi Mumbai

Manish Packers and Movers Pvt Ltd said...


Reliable Movers and Packers in India for Moving and Shifting Door to Door Transportation Services to all over India. Visit More :-
Manish Packers and Movers Pvt Ltd Blog
Packers and Movers Bhopal
Packers and Movers Jabalpur
Packers and Movers Vadodara
Packers and Movers Udaipur
Packers and Movers Jaipur
Packers and Movers Chandigarh
Packers adn Movers Chennai
Packers and Movers Hyderabad
Movers and Packers in Indore

Manish Packers and Movers Pvt Ltd said...

Manish Packers and Movers Pvt Ltd - Best Packers and Movers in India for Professional Packing and Moving Services to all over India. Visit More :-
Manish Packers and Movers Pvt Ltd
Packers and Movers Bangalore
Packers and Movers Gurgaon
Packers and Movers Indore
Packers and Movers Kolkata
Packers and Movers Mumbai
Packers and Movers Nagpur
Packers and Movers Ahmedabad
Manish Packers in Indore
Manish Packers and Movers Pvt Ltd Sitemap